Pre-Order: Cupid's Mix Valentine's Day Cookie Box


Flowers are nice, but cookies are better! Our fun and festive Valentine's Day collection comes with an assortment of 18 individually wrapped cookies, including:

  • You're So Classic (because you are!)
  • Limited Edition - Nutty By Nature (a peanut butter lover's dream!)
  • Valentine's Day Birthday Cake

Make your gift extra special by adding a handwritten note at checkout! 

Meghan's Tip: Microwave the Nutty by Nature peanut butter cookies for 8-10 seconds. Thank us later!


Each Bestseller Cookie Box includes a total of 18 individually wrapped cookies.

You’re So Classic - Soft-baked chocolate chip cookie, vanilla bean, bourbon

Nutty by Nature - Soft-baked peanut butter cookie, bourbon, Belgian chocolate & peanut butter chips, flaked sea salt

Birthday Cake (Under 21 Club) - Soft-baked brown sugar cookie, white chocolate chips, Valentine’s sprinkle mix

Items are baked fresh and shipped directly from our headquarters in Nashville.

Buttercream Blondie ships Monday-Tuesday of each week.

Due to the perishable nature of our products, we recommend you choose 2-day shipping.

No deliveries Saturday or Sunday.
Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.

*Please note: All items are made in the same facility and may contain wheat, nuts, peanuts, eggs, milk, and soy.

You may also like

Recently viewed